Comparisons

USPS vs UPS vs FedEx: which is cheapest?

Understand where each carrier wins by weight, size, and distance—without surprises.

Quick Answer: When Each Carrier Wins

USPS wins for lightweight packages under 1 lb, short-zone deliveries (zones 1-4), and PO Box addresses. UPS wins for heavier packages (5+ lbs), longer zones (5-8), business addresses, and when you need reliable tracking. FedEx wins for time-definite express shipping, residential ground in certain regions, and international priority. The "cheapest" carrier depends entirely on your specific package profile—weight, dimensions, origin, and destination.

Cost Comparison: USPS Services

USPS Ground Advantage is often the cheapest option for packages under 1 lb, starting around $4-5 for zone 1-4 deliveries. Priority Mail offers 1-3 day delivery with included insurance ($100) and tracking, typically $8-15 for small packages. Priority Mail Express guarantees overnight or 2-day delivery starting around $26. Key USPS advantage: No residential surcharges, delivery to PO Boxes, and Saturday delivery included. USPS uses a more favorable DIM divisor (166 vs 139), making it better for lightweight, larger packages.

Cost Comparison: UPS Services

UPS Ground is competitive for heavier packages (5+ lbs) and longer zones. Typical costs: $10-20 for packages in the 5-15 lb range. UPS 2nd Day Air and Next Day Air are premium options for time-sensitive shipments. UPS adds a residential surcharge (~$4-6) but offers business-to-business rates that can beat USPS. UPS excels in tracking reliability and package handling for fragile items. Their SurePost service (UPS pickup, USPS final mile) can save money on residential deliveries.

Cost Comparison: FedEx Services

FedEx Ground is priced similarly to UPS Ground for most weights and zones. FedEx Home Delivery is specifically designed for residential addresses and can be cheaper than UPS residential in some regions. FedEx Express (Overnight, 2Day) competes directly with UPS Express services. FedEx SmartPost (similar to UPS SurePost) uses FedEx for linehaul and USPS for last mile. FedEx is often the best choice for express international shipping to certain destinations.

Weight Break Points

Under 1 lb: USPS Ground Advantage usually wins by $2-4 over UPS/FedEx. 1-5 lbs: USPS and UPS/FedEx are often close; compare by zone. 5-15 lbs: UPS/FedEx Ground become more competitive, especially for zones 5+. 15-70 lbs: UPS/FedEx typically win; consider freight for 150+ lbs. Over 70 lbs: Requires freight or LTL services. These are general guidelines—always get live quotes because carrier pricing changes frequently and negotiated rates can shift the economics significantly.

Zone Impact on Pricing

Zones 1-4 (shorter distances): USPS often wins on price and transit time is similar. Zones 5-6 (medium distances): UPS/FedEx Ground become competitive; transit times stretch to 4-5 days. Zones 7-8 (cross-country): UPS/FedEx may win on price; transit times extend to 5-7 days for ground. Zone pricing is why origin ZIP code matters so much. A seller in Ohio shipping nationally has a cost advantage over coastal sellers shipping coast-to-coast.

Surcharges to Watch

Residential surcharges: UPS/FedEx add $4-6; USPS does not. Additional Handling: Triggered by weight (over 50 lbs), dimensions (over 48" or 30"), or packaging type (not fully encased). Oversized: Packages over 96" in length + girth face $40+ surcharges. Delivery Area Surcharges (DAS): Remote areas cost extra—USPS has better coverage without surcharges. Fuel surcharges: UPS/FedEx add 5-15% on top of base rates; built into USPS rates. These surcharges can completely flip which carrier is cheapest.

Transit Time Comparison

For ground services across the country (zone 8): USPS Ground Advantage: 2-5 business days. UPS Ground: 5-7 business days. FedEx Ground: 5-7 business days. FedEx Home Delivery: 5-7 business days (includes Saturday). For express services: USPS Priority Mail Express: 1-2 days guaranteed. UPS Next Day Air: Next business day guaranteed. FedEx Overnight: Next business day guaranteed. USPS often has faster ground transit times but less time-definite guarantees.

Tracking and Reliability

UPS and FedEx provide more granular tracking with driver-level updates and photo proof of delivery. USPS tracking has improved but can be less detailed. For high-value shipments, UPS/FedEx offer more robust claims processes. USPS is excellent for everyday e-commerce but may have more variability during peak seasons. Consider which level of tracking visibility your customers expect.

The Best Strategy: Multi-Carrier Shipping

The smartest shippers don't pick one carrier—they use all three strategically. Use USPS for: Lightweight packages, short zones, PO Boxes, and Flat Rate when it makes sense. Use UPS for: Heavier packages, business addresses, and when tracking reliability is critical. Use FedEx for: Express shipping, certain residential regions, and international priority. A shipping platform like ShipWave automatically compares rates across all carriers and picks the cheapest option for each shipment.

FAQs

Which is cheapest: USPS, UPS, or FedEx?
It depends on package weight, dimensions, and destination. Generally, USPS is cheapest for packages under 1 lb and short zones. UPS/FedEx Ground become more competitive for heavier packages (5+ lbs) and longer zones. Always compare rates for your specific package profile.
Does USPS have residential surcharges?
No, USPS does not charge residential surcharges. UPS and FedEx typically add $4-6 per package for residential deliveries. This makes USPS significantly cheaper for B2C e-commerce when shipping to homes.
Which carrier is fastest for ground shipping?
USPS Ground Advantage is often faster with 2-5 day delivery nationwide. UPS and FedEx Ground typically take 5-7 days for cross-country shipments. However, UPS and FedEx ground services have more consistent, predictable transit times.
Can UPS and FedEx deliver to PO Boxes?
No, UPS and FedEx Ground cannot deliver to PO Boxes—only USPS can. However, UPS SurePost and FedEx SmartPost use USPS for final-mile delivery and may be able to reach some PO Box addresses.
Which carrier has the best tracking?
UPS and FedEx offer more detailed tracking with driver updates and delivery photos. USPS tracking has improved but is generally less granular. For high-value items where customers expect detailed tracking, UPS or FedEx may provide better visibility.
How do fuel surcharges affect pricing?
UPS and FedEx add fuel surcharges (typically 5-15%) on top of base rates that fluctuate monthly. USPS builds fuel costs into their base rates, so you see the final price upfront. This can make USPS pricing more predictable but not necessarily cheaper.
Start printing labels →

Shipping Guides You Might Find Useful

UPS Ground vs FedEx Ground: Which Carrier Should You Choose?

UPS and FedEx Ground are nearly identical in price and speed. Your choice should depend on pickup convenience, account discounts, and destination coverage.

E-commerce Shipping Solutions: Scale Your Online Business

The right shipping strategy can make or break your e-commerce business. Compare carriers instantly, automate label creation, and deliver exceptional customer experiences.

USPS vs DHL for International Shipping: Budget vs Speed

USPS Priority Mail International costs 40-60% less than DHL Express but takes 6-10 days vs 2-4 days.

Related Resources

Explore more guides and tools for your shipping needs

Comparisons

ShipWave vs Pirate Ship: Full Comparison (2025)

Compare carrier discounts, UPS/USPS rates, features, and ease of use between these two free shipping platforms.

Comparisons

ShipWave vs EasyPost: Full Comparison (2025)

Compare no-code shipping labels vs API-first carrier integration for your business needs.

Comparisons

ShipWave vs Stamps.com: Full Comparison (2025)

Compare modern multi-carrier shipping with legacy USPS-only postage to find the right fit.

Comparisons

Ground vs Priority vs 2‑Day: when to upgrade

Balance cost vs delivery promise; upgrade only when it moves the needle.

Comparisons

ShipWave vs USPS Click-N-Ship: Full Comparison (2025)

Compare free USPS labels vs discounted multi-carrier shipping to find the best option.

Comparisons

ShipWave vs Shippo: Full Comparison (2025)

Compare pricing models, discount rates, integrations, and ease of use to pick the right shipping platform.